If you know about the Debian Code of Conduct then check out this comic, it kind of says it all.
A few months ago I was showing my friend Bruno Souza the work I had been doing with my childhood friend and robotics genius, David Hanson. I had been watching what David was going through in his process of creating life-like robots with the limited industrial software available for motor control. I had suggested to David that binding motors to Blender control structures was a genuinely viable possibility. David talked with his forward looking CEO, Jong Lee, and they were gracious enough to invite me to Hong Kong to make this exciting idea a reality. Working closely the HRI team (Vytas, Gabrielos, Fabien and Davide) with David’s friend and collaborators at OpenCog (Ben Goertzel, Mandeep, David, Jamie, Alex and Samuel) a month long creative hack-fest yielded pretty amazing results.
Bruno is an avid puppeteer, a global organizer of java user groups and creator of Juggy the Java Finch, mascot of Java users and user groups everywhere. We started talking about how cool it would be to have a robot version of Juggy. When I was in China I had spent a little time playing with Mark Tilden’s RSMedia and various versions of David’s hobby servo based emotive heads. Bruno and I did a little research into the ROS Java bindings for the Robot Operating System and decided that if we could make that part of the picture we had a great and fun idea for a JavaOne talk.
Hunting and gathering
I tracked down a fairly priced RSMedia in Alaska, Bruno put a pair of rubber Juggy puppet heads in the mail and we were on our way.
We had decided that we wanted RoboJuggy to be able to run about untethered and the new RaspberryPi B+ seemed like the perfect low power brain to make that happen. I like the Debian based Raspbian distributions but had lately started using the “netinst” Pi images. These get your Pi up and running in about 15 minutes with a nicely minimalistic install instead of a pile of dependencies you probably don’t need. I’d recommend anyone interested I’m duplicating our work to stay their journey there:
Robots seem like an embedded application but ROS only ships packages for Ubuntu. I was pleasantly surprised that there are very good instructions for building ROS from source on the Pi. I ended up following these instructions:
Building from source means that all your install ends up being “isolated” (in ROS speak) and your file locations and build instructions end up being subtly current. As explained in the linked article, this process is also very time consuming. One thing I would recommend once you get past this step is to use the UNIX dd command to back up your entire SD card to a desktop. This way if you make a mess of things in later steps you can restore your install to a pristine Raspbian+ROS install. If your SD drive was on /dev/sdb you might use something like this to do the job:
sudo dd bs=4M if=/dev/sdb | gzip > /home/your_username/image`date +%d%m%y`.gz
Getting Java in the mix
Once you have your Pi all set up with minimal Raspbian and ROS you are going to want a Java VM. The Pi runs the ARM CPU so you need the corresponding version of Java. I tried getting things going initially with OpenJDK and I had some issues with that. I will work on resolving that in the future because I would like to have a 100% Free Software kit for this but since this was for JavaOne I also wanted JDK8, which isn’t available in Debian yet. So, I downloaded the Oracle JDK8 package for ARM.
At this point you are ready to start installing the ROS Java packages. I’m pretty sure the way I did this initially is wrong but I was trying to reconcile the two install procedures for ROS Java and ROS Hydro for Raspberry Pi. I started by following these directions for ROS Java but with a few exceptions (you have to click the “install from source link” in the page to see the right stuff:
Now these instructions are good but this is a Pi running Debian and not an Ubuntu install. You won’t run the apt-get package commands because those tools were already installed in your earlier steps. Also, this creates its own workspace and we really want these packages all in one workspace. You can apparently “chain” workspaces in ROS but I didn’t understand this well enough to get it working so what I did was this:
> mkdir -p ~/rosjava > wstool init -j4 ~/rosjava/src https://raw.github.com/rosjava/rosjava/hydro/rosjava.rosinstall > source ~/ros_catkin_ws/install_isolated/setup.bash > cd ~/rosjava # Make sure we've got all rosdeps and msg packages. > rosdep update > rosdep install --from-paths src -i -y
and then copied the sources installed into ~/rosjava/src into my main ~/ros_catkin_ws/src. Once those were copied over I was able to run a standard build.
> catkin_make_isolated --install
Like the main ROS install this process will take a little while. The Java gradle builds take an especially long time. One thing I would recommend to speed up your workflow is to have an x86 Debian install (native desktop, QEMU instance, docker, whatever) and do these same “build from source” installs there. This will let you try your steps out on a much faster system before you try them out in the Pi. That can be a big time saver.
Putting together the pieces
Around this time my RSMedia had finally showed up from Alaska. At first I thought I had a broken unit because it would power up, complain about not passing system tests and then shut back down. It turns out that if you just put the D batteries in and miss the four AAs that it will kind of pretend to be working so watch for that mistake. Here is a picture of the RSMedia when it first came out of the box:
Other parts were starting to roll in as well. The rubber puppet heads had made their way through Brazilian customs and my Pololu Mini Maestro 24 had also shown up as well as the my servo motors and pan and tilt camera rig. I had previously bought a set of 10 motors for goofing around so I bought the pan and tilt rig by itself for about $5(!) but you can buy a complete set for around $25 from a number of EBay stores.
A bit more about the Pololu. This astonishing little motor controller costs about $25 and gives you control of 24 motors with an easy to use and high level serial API. It is probably also possible to control these servos directly from the Pi and eliminate this board but that will be genuinely difficult because of the real-time timing issues. For $25 this thing is a real gem and you won’t regret buying it.
Now it was time to start dissecting the RSMedia and getting control of its brain. Unfortunately a lot of great information about the RSMedia has floated away since it was in its heyday 5 years ago but there is still some solid information out there that we need to round up and preserve. A great resource is the SourceForge based website here at http://rsmediadevkit.sourceforge.net.
That site has links to a number of useful sites. You will definitely want to check out their wiki. To disassemble the RSMedia I followed their instructions. I will say, it would be smart to take more pictures as you are going because they don’t take as many as they should. I took pictures of each board and its associated connections as dismantled the unit and that helped me get things back together later. Another important note is that if all you want to do is solder onto the control board and not replace the head then its feasible to solder the board in place without completely disassembling the unit. Here are some photos of the dis-assembly:
Now I also had to start adjusting the puppet head, building an armature for the motors to control it and hooking it into the robot. I need to take some more photos of the actual armature. I like to use cardboard for this kind of stuff because it is so fast to work with and relatively strong. One trick I have also learned about cardboard is that if you get something going with it and you need it to be a little more production strength you can paint it down with fiberglass resin from your local auto store. Once it dries it becomes incredibly tough because it soaks through the fibers of the cardboard and hardens around them. You will want to do this in a well ventilated area but its a great way to build super tough prototypes.
Another prototyping trick I can suggest is using a combination of Velcro and zipties to hook things together. The result is surprisingly strong and still easy to take apart if things aren’t working out. Velcro self-adhesive pads stick to rubber like magic and that is actually how I hooked the jaw servo onto the mask. You can see me torturing its first initial connection here:
Since the puppet head had come all the way from Brazil I decided to cook some chicken hearts in the churrascaria style while I worked on them in the garage. This may sound gross but I’m telling you, you need to try it! I soaked mine in soy sauce, Sriracha and chinese cooking wine. Delicious but I digress.
As I was eating my chicken hearts I was also connecting the pan and tilt armature onto the puppet’s jaw and eye assembly. It took me most of the evening to get all this going but by about one in the morning things were starting to look good!
I only had a few days left to hack things together before JavaOne and things were starting to get tight. I had so much to do and had also started to run into some nasty surprises with the ROS Java control software. It turns out that ROS Java is less than friendly with ROS message structures that are not “built in”. I had tried to follow the provided instructions but was not (and still have not) been able to get that working.
I still needed to get control of the RSMedia. Doing that required the delicate operation of soldering to its control board. On the board there are a set of pins that provide a serial interface to the ARM based embedded Linux computer that controls the robot. To do that I followed these excellent instructions:
After some sweaty time bent over a magnifying glass I had success:
I had previously purchased the USB-TTL232 accessory described in the article from Dallas’ awesome Tanner Electronics store in Dallas. If you are a geek I would recommend that you go there and say hi to its proprietor (and walking encyclopedia of electronics knowledge) Jim Tanner.
It was very gratifying when I started a copy of minicom, set it to 115200, N, 8, 1, plugged in the serial widget to the RSMedia and booted it up. I was greeted with a clearly recognizable Linux startup and console prompt. At first I thought I had done something wrong because I couldn’t get it to respond to commands but I quickly realized I had flow control turned on. Once turned off I was able to navigate around the file system, execute commands and have some fun. A little research and I found this useful resource which let me get all kinds of body movements going:
At this point, I had a usable set of controls for the body as well as the neck armature. I had a controller running the industry’s latest and greatest robotics framework that could run on the RSMedia without being tethered to power and I had most of a connection to Java going. Now I just had to get all those pieces working together. The only problem is that time was running out and I only had a couple of days until my talk and still had to pack and square things away at work.
The last day was spent doing things that I wouldn’t be able to do on the road. My brother Erik (and fantastic artist) came over to help paint up the juggy head and fix the eyeball armature. He used a mix of oil paint, rubber cement which stuck to the mask beautifully.
I bought battery packs for the USB Pi power and the 6v motor control and integrated them into a box that could sit below the neck armature. I fixed up a cloth neck sleeve that could cover everything. Luckily during all this my beautiful and ever so supportive girlfriend Becca had helped me get packed or I probably wouldn’t have made it out the door.
Welcome to San Francisco
THIS ARTICLE IS STILL BEING WRITTEN
Its pretty mind blowing that the National Review is trying to assert a causal effect between getting an abortion and doing drugs but that is what they do in their latest article about Texas gubernatorial candidate Wendy Davis.
They even go on to assert that abortion will make you beat any children you have later and become mentally ill. I don’t suppose it occurs to them that the life situations that lead you to an abortion might also include drug use or mental illness. The article is pretty vague about whether there is a correlation between abortion and the onset of these conditions. I personally wouldn’t be surprised to find that mentally ill, child abusing drug addicts are statistically more likely to get an abortion but, then again, I might be profiling people.
Frankly, I cannot believe that they have lowered themselves to these kinds of tactics. They aren’t just slinging mud and Wendy Davis but at women in general and the intelligence of their readers.
My friend Russell Fish and I are heading down to Austin for the APS Sunset Review. The Sunset Review is a process where the state legislature reviews services and programs provided by the government and determines if they are obsolete, duplicated or unnecessary. We are going to present the troubling cases we have found where APS has seized personal assets and moved people into institutions against their will. We don’t see this particular service as something that benefits the people of the state of Texas. Hopefully we can bring these activities under closer review and even eliminate them for the many elderly people who can manage their own affairs.
Work on the ROS/Blender robotics control pipeline has culminated in the integration of the system with the tiny robotic Einstein head that had been living at Polytechnic University under the watchful eye of the OpenCog group. Back at Hanson Robotics, tiny Einstein was mercilessly ripped apart and his head attached to an absurdly long robot snake neck apparatus that mimics the configuration of the upcoming “Dmitroid” robot system. Once suitably mutated, tiny Einstein was able to make a few statements and even sing a couple of tunes.
Progress continues as we use Blender to control ROS based Dynamixels. Now the jaw moves and the eyeballs are in. Soon we should be able to demonstrate targeting of the eyes to various kinds of objects.
All the motors start talking to Blender through ROS. Some interesting shaky behavior and a few issues with inverse kinematics are revealed.
We continue to make progress on the robot arm rig, connecting a Blender IK powered bone rig to dynamixel motors controlled through ROS.
The blend file is available at the Hanson Robotics GitHub site here:
Oracle has demonstrated that implementing an API is effectively the same as copying code from a program. To me, as a non-lawyer programmer, this surprising court decision seems to mutate copyrights into a kind of Software-Patent-Lite(tm) without the benefit of examiners or a 15 year term limit. This seems like a chilling new tool for deep pockets companies like Oracle to go about tormenting people. Thinking more deeply, however, you begin to wonder if Oracle hasn’t inadvertently created some kind of Free Software Doomsday weapon.
After all, if simply implementing an API makes you code a “derivative work” then doesn’t that mean the terms of the GPL will apply on any code that implements the API of a GPL’d system? Even if you didn’t copy code you have implemented that API and according to Oracle that’s a derived work. If you ask me, its the most excitingly vauge and contagious information phenomena since the Open Data Base License.